2020 brainfood prabhu cycles of poverty 883x432 1

Cycles of poverty

30 March 2020

The article at a glance

How will income inequality deepen problems during the COVID-19 (coronavirus) crisis? While some are relying on friends and neighbours to help them …

Category: Insight

How will income inequality deepen problems during the COVID-19 (coronavirus) crisis?

Illustration of city with a wealth divide.

While some are relying on friends and neighbours to help them get groceries during the COVID-19 crisis, the poor may need to put themselves at risk of COVID-19 by venturing out on public transportation to get supplies. Depending on where they live, they may trust no one else to help out.

This is true in areas with the highest levels of income inequality, where the poor are less likely to rely on their community for support due to shame or embarrassment, according to a paper to be published on Monday 30 March in Nature Human Behaviour.

A good example is New Haven, Connecticut, home to the prestigious Yale University. Part of the city is a wealthier University area, and the other part is primarily low income. It would be rare, the research suggests, for someone from the lower-income areas to ask those in the University section for help – especially now as the coronavirus continues to spread.   

Professor Jaideep Prabhu
Professor Jaideep Prabhu

“Policymakers have rightly sought to help lower-income individuals, and this remains vital around the world,” says study co-author Jaideep Prabhu, Professor of Marketing at University of Cambridge Judge Business School. “But our findings show the importance of also building stronger communities, and the coronavirus crisis underscores the need for this given the new routines stemming from the crisis.”

The paper, entitled “Higher economic inequality intensifies the financial hardship of people living in poverty by fraying the community buffer”, is co-authored by Dr Jon Jachimowicz of Harvard University, Professor Elke Weber of Princeton University, Dr Barnabas Szaszi of Eotvos Lorand University in Budapest, Dr Marcel Lukas of Heriot-Watt University in Edinburgh, Dr David Smerdon of the University of Queensland in Australia, and Professor Jaideep Prabhu of Cambridge Judge Business School.

“If I’m poor, it exacerbates my need to rely on community, but what does it mean if I don’t trust my community? It means that there is no way for me to get what I need without putting myself in danger. This can have disastrous long-term effects among the poor,” said study lead author Jon Jachimowicz of Harvard.

“Our work shows that hardship increases for low-income individuals by reducing their ability to rely on their community as a buffer against financial and other related difficulties,” said co-author Elke Weber of Princeton. “This suggests that stimulus measures designed to address the economic and social fallout of the coronavirus should focus on reducing the existing income and wealth gap in our country.”

The study was an interdisciplinary effort led by psychologists and economists using data analysis strategies across disciplines.

The researchers conducted eight studies looking at more than one million people across the United States, Australia, and Uganda. Their work included an instrumental variable analysis, lab experiments, online studies, and fieldwork.

In the first four studies, the team established empirical support for their hypothesis that greater income inequality hits the poor the hardest. Their findings were as expected: Across all countries, the greater the economic inequality, the harder the financial hardship for those with the lowest incomes.

In the next four studies, they investigated the main driver behind this effect, finding strong evidence supporting their claim: Higher economic inequality weakens the perception of a community buffer, which is a key source of support for low-income people.

The researchers estimated this lack of support comes at a cost $6,587. This means that a person earning $36,587 in New Haven, where there is greater income inequality, experiences the same financial hardship as someone making $30,000 in a more homogenous income area like Princeton.

So, why do low-income people feel they can’t ask community members for support? Many people hit by money problems worry about what others would think, so they don’t ask for help. The researchers actually found that the higher the income inequality in an area, the more distrustful the poor are of those in their community.

Other factors are also perpetuating cycles of poverty in these places. One is a person’s need to display his or her wealth for reasons of status through physical objects like a fancy car, which further indebts them. In other cases, people overwhelmed by destitution may resort to negative behaviours like taking out payday loans to cover the bills, which only worsens their financial situation.

All of this supports the strengthening of local communities, the researchers said. Programs like the YMCA are extremely beneficial, and community investment funds could further empower towns with the greatest income disparity. Infrastructure also matters; a city’s walkability can bond neighbours together. In light of COVID-19, stimulus bills could help address some of these issues, while financially helping the most vulnerable.

“At a time when the coronavirus crisis puts a premium on cooperation and community support, our policymakers need to be aware of the social and economic conditions that eat away at such support, especially for the most vulnerable among us, the poor,” Weber said.

The results do not shed light on how economic inequality affects people at median income levels, so the researchers encourage further work in this area. It is possible that the availability of liquid assets and other kinds of wealth could help in times of need, the researchers said.

Find out more

Visit Professor Jaideep Prabhu’s faculty webpage